THE RISKS OF PRIVATIZING GOVERNMENT SERVICES

Privatization of government services, promoted by Republicans and some Democrats, rarely delivers greater efficiency. Over 40% of the federal government workforce are now private contractors. The DOD uses contractors extensively; its contracts with Musk’s SpaceX present national security risks.

SUMMARY: Privatization of government services has been promoted by Republicans and some Democrats for over 40 years. Their promises of greater efficiency rarely turn out to be true. Over 40% of the federal government’s workforce are now private contractors. The Department of Defense uses contractors extensively, including for sensitive, mission-critical functions. Its contracts with Elon Musk’s SpaceX company present serious national security risks.

(Note: If you find a post too long to read, please just skim the bolded portions. Thanks for reading my blog!)

(Note: Please follow me and see my blog posts on Bluesky at: @jalippitt.bsky.social. Thanks!)

(Note: For lots of good news see Jess Craven’s Chop Wood Carry Water blog’s most recent Sunday post here.)

Privatization of government services or “outsourcing” has been promoted by Republicans and some Democrats for over 40 years. Proponents claim it will save taxpayers money, improve public services, and increase public sector accountability. This rarely turns out to be true. Once the profit incentive is introduced, prices are likely to go up and quality is likely to go down. Privatization only tends to be successful if there is strong oversight and regulation, as well as real competition.  (See this previous post for more details.)

Poor experiences with privatization at the municipal level led to a wave of de-privatization between 1997 and 2002. Nonetheless, privatization continued to march ahead at the federal level. (I’ve been criticizing privatization since way back in 2012. See previous posts here and here for more information.)

Numerous examples exist of privatization’s failure to deliver its promised benefits. The U.S. health care system is a classic one. The privatized, for-profit system in the U.S. is the costliest system among any of our peer countries and its outcomes are among the worst. All elements of the system are putting profits before patients. (See previous posts here and here for more information on the failures of for-profit health care.)

Other examples of failed privatization include:

  • Rail transportation is more efficient, dependable, and convenient in the rest of the world than with the privatized system in the U.S.
  • Bridges, roads, and parking meters that have been privatized by state and municipal governments often did not produce the desired results.
  • Water, sewer, and solid waste disposal systems’ privatization has been found in most studies to provide no cost or efficiency benefits.
  • Internet service is cheaper and faster where there are municipally run systems and in Europe.

Privatization is also evident in the increasing portion of the federal workforce that is contractors. The total federal government workforce of roughly 9.1 million people can be categorized as follows: [1]

  • 3.7 million contractors (40.7%),
  • 2.0 million civilian employees (22.0%),
  • 1.6 million people paid through various grant programs (17.6%),
  • 1.3 million active-duty military personnel (14.3%), and
  • 0.5 million Postal Service employees (5.5%). [2]

The use of contractors by the Department of Defense (DOD) on the ground in war zones has gone largely unnoticed. However, more contractors have died (8,000) than US service members (7,000) in post 9/11 military activities. Contractors have become a permanent element of the military infrastructure. In the Middle East region, operational and battlefield contractors greatly outnumbered military personnel (43,800 contractors to 15,000 military) in October 2020. There were three contractors for each member of the military in Afghanistan at the end of U.S. involvement in August 2021. [3]

But the DOD’s privatization goes further and, as has become apparent recently, is jeopardizing national security and U.S. foreign policy. The U.S. DOD has billions of dollars of contracts with Elon Musk’s SpaceX company to provide critical military and national security capabilities. For example, Space X has a multi-billion-dollar contract to build a classified spy satellite network for the DOD. It also has contracts for communication services through Space X’s subsidiary, Starlink. [4]

Recently, Trump and Musk were limiting Ukraine’s use of Starlink and its military version, Starshield. Musk claims that Starshield is operated by the US government. The limitations that were imposed on these communications services prevented or slowed warnings of incoming Russian missiles and drones, and also degraded Ukraine’s offensive military capabilities. [5]

It seems likely that the U.S. DOD is similarly dependent on SpaceX communications capabilities. It doesn’t seem wise or safe to have privatized these DOD mission critical capabilities.

Furthermore, Musk is considered a significant national security risk by DOD and intelligence officials, as well as by other intelligence experts. [6] When Trump took office in 2025, there were three DOD investigations of Musk’s and Space X’s repeated failures to file mandatory national security reports of contacts and involvement with foreign entities. [7] Their significant contacts and engagement with Chinese leaders and investors make this a matter of serious concern. Space X has sizeable investments from Chinese investors, but because of its contracts with the DOD, Space X does not want its investments from Chinese investors to be public knowledge. Therefore, it actively works to make sure those investments are laundered through intermediate entities in the Cayman Islands and elsewhere, which keeps investors anonymous. [8]

Roughly half of Musk’s Tesla vehicles are built in China and China is Tesla’s largest market. Tesla’s largest factory is in Shanghai and its construction received a $2.8 billion investment, major tax breaks, and special permissions from the Chinese government. Musk regularly meets with Chinese government and Communist Party officials due to his multiple business interests, current and future, in China.

It seems quite clear that sensitive DOD capabilities should not be privatized to Musk’s company – or anyone else’s for that matter.

My next post will focus on the need to slow, stop, and eventually reverse the privatization of essential government functions.


[1]      Gordon, N., 10/5/17, “Contractors and the true size of government,” Project On Government Oversight (https://www.pogo.org/analyses/contractors-and-true-size-of-government)

[2]      Note: These data are from 2017, but overall these numbers have been relatively stable over time. If anything, the percentage of contractors has increased.

[3]      Cancian, M., 8/30/21, “In Afghanistan, contractors were unsung heroes of US efforts,” Breaking Defense (https://breakingdefense.com/2021/08/in-afghanistan-contractors-were-unsung-heroes-of-us-efforts/)

[4]      Elordi, M., 10/21/24, “Elon Musk’s companies have faced at least 20 federal probes,” Daily Wire (https://www.dailywire.com/news/elon-musks-companies-have-faced-at-least-20-federal-probes-report)

[5]      Roth, A. 10/14/26, “Ukrainian military’s access to Starlink satellite internet suddenly restricted,” The Guardian (https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/oct/14/ukraine-soldiers-combat-access-starlink-satellite-internet-restricted)

[6]      Reich, R., 3/21/25, “Is the Muskrat working for China?” Robert Reich blog (https://robertreich.substack.com/p/is-the-muskrat-working-for-china )

[7]      House Committee on the Judiciary, 2/13/25, “Fact Sheet: Trump administration, DOGE punish agencies investigating Elon Musk’s companies,” (https://democrats-judiciary.house.gov/uploadedfiles/2025.02.13_fact_sheet_re_musk_investigations.pdf

[8]      Kaplan, J., & Elliott, J., 3/26/25, “How Elon Musk’s Space X secretly allows investments from China,” ProPublica (https://www.propublica.org/article/elon-musk-spacex-allows-china-investment-cayman-islands-secrecy)

WHAT DEMOCRATS SHOULD BE DOING

Democrats should be taking steps now to lay the ground work for electoral successes and policy making in the future. Running against Trump is not enough; Democrats need to state what they are for. They should ban super PAC and dark money from their primaries and support progressive policies.

SUMMARY: Democrats should be taking steps now within the national party and at the state level to lay the ground work for electoral successes and for policy making in the future. Running against Trump is not enough; Democrats need to clearly state what they are for. Americans support progressive policy solutions. The Democratic National Committee (DNC) and state committees should ban super PAC and dark money from their primary elections.

(Note: If you find a post too long to read, please just skim the bolded portions. Thanks for reading my blog!)

(Note: Please follow me and get notices of my blog posts on Bluesky at: @jalippitt.bsky.social. Thanks!)

While Democrats have very limited influence on national policy right now, there’s a lot they should be doing now within the national party and at the state level to lay the ground work for electoral successes and for policy making in the future. My previous two series of blog posts on fair taxation and the affordability crisis identified policies that Democrats should be supporting at the national and state level, and enacting now at the state level.

Electorally, running against Trump is not enough; Democrats need to clearly state what they are for. Sure, Trump is a convicted criminal and unpopular, but nobody cares about that if they cannot afford basic needs and they think Trump and the Republicans will address the affordability crisis better than Democrats. That’s what happened in 2024 in a nutshell.

Voters will not believe Democrats are serious about addressing the affordability crisis if they don’t unequivocally embrace progressive remedies, as Senators Warren (D-MA) and Sanders (I-VT) and Representative Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), among others, have been doing. Opponents, including Democrats, call their policies “too progressive,” which is code for opposition to any policy that favors working Americans over the oligarchs.

The real split among Democrats is between (a) Democrats on the take from the oligarchs of the crypto industry, Big Tech and AI businesses, and Wall Street; and (b) Democrats who are standing up for working Americans and against the oligarchs and their monopolistic companies. It’s that split that deprives Democrats of unity and of a consistent message that resonates with the real frustrations of everyday Americans. Democrats need to acknowledge the failures of our rigged economic system and clearly advocate for structural changes to the status quo that would: [1]

  • Boost pay including by raising the minimum wage
  • Build more affordable homes and crack down on corporate landlords
  • Increase Social Security checks
  • Provide universal child care
  • Block price gouging
  • Strengthen unions
  • Establish universal health care
  • Tax the wealthy and giant corporations
  • Stop members of Congress from buying and selling stock and crypto assets (i.e., insider trading)

For years, polling data have repeatedly shown that Americans support progressive policy solutions to the challenges they face in their daily lives. For example, over 70 percent of Americans support Medicare for All, which would make health insurance more affordable and health care more accessible and less fraught. Seventy percent believe our tax system is unfair, while 66% support universal free child care. More broadly, 66% of Democrats now view socialism favorably, while only 42% view capitalism favorably. [2]

To enact this policy agenda and to get Democrats to unequivocally support it, billionaires must be stopped from buying our elections and our policy making process. A Democratic Party that worries more about offending wealthy donors than enacting policies that support working Americans will not succeed. Democrats should refuse campaign money from organizations and individuals opposed to basic workers’ rights and a strong social safety net.

As a first step, the Democratic National Committee (DNC) and state committees should ban super PAC and dark money (i.e., money where the true donor is unidentified) from their primary elections. Unfortunately, the DNC recently voted for a resolution that simply condemned the influence of dark and corporate money in Democratic primaries. It needs to go further and ban such money, which it can do, given that it sets the rules for its own primary elections. Corporate and Republican-linked super PACs and dark money organizations spent over $200 million in 2024 Democratic primaries. Their goal, sometimes successful, was to defeat progressive Democrats, particularly ones opposing Israel’s genocidal war on the Palestinians. [3] The Israel, crypto, and AI interests have been, and will in 2026, skew Democratic primaries and candidates to ones supporting their interests, which are not the interests of mainstream Democrats and Americans.

A ban on super PACs and dark money would force Democrats to turn to smaller donations from regular people, as Senators Warren (D-MA) and Sanders (I-VT) and New York City Mayor Mamdani have successfully done. This is what democracy, as opposed to oligarchy, looks like.

I encourage you to contact your state and local elected officials, as well as your U.S. Representative and Senators, to ask them to support policies that support working Americans. If any of these officials are Democrats, I urge you to point out that just running against Trump isn’t enough, as we saw in 2024, and that they need to run on what they stand for. [4]

If you’re frustrated that the Democrats aren’t unequivocally supporting working Americans, you might want to look at and perhaps support the Working Families Party. They’ve put forth a platform, their Working Families Guarantee, which is reminiscent of FDR’s economic bill of rights. It includes:

  • A home you can afford
  • Healthcare you can rely on
  • A good job to support your family
  • Childcare when and where you need it
  • Paid family and medical leave
  • Taxing the rich, and
  • Getting big money out of politics.

For lots of good news, see Jess Craven’s Chop Wood Carry Water blog’s most recent good news Sunday post here.


[1]      Warren, E., 1/12/26, “The Democratic Party is at a crossroads,” The Nation (https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/elizabeth-warren-democrats-2026-midterms/)

[2]      Meyerson, H., 1/7/26, “The Democratic base is social democratic,” The American Prospect (https://prospect.org/2026/01/07/democratic-base-socialist-democratic-zohran-mamdani-medicare-for-all/)

[3]      Wilkins, B., 4/10/26, “DNC half-measures condemning dark money won’t cut it, says Sanders as he demands total ban,” Common Dreams (https://www.commondreams.org/news/bernie-dark-money-ban)

[4]     You can find contact information for your US Representative at http://www.house.gov/representatives/find/ and for your US Senators at http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_cfm.cfm.